Where Men Win Glory---Jon Krakauer
Thursday, February 4, 2010 at 8:27AM 
Like many people, I didn’t know that much about Pat Tillman past the much rehashed fact that he walked away from a multi-million dollar NFL contract to join the Army. In Where Men Win Glory, Krakauer delves deep into the life and upbringing of Pat Tillman, and his decision to join the Army. It was refreshing, and also surprising, that Tillman was not very fond of the majority of the Army. His journal, which the Tillman family has graciously allowed Krakauer access to, paints a picture of a man trying to do the right thing, but conflicted with his personal opinions of the government from which he takes orders. Although he is strong in his conviction of fighting for America, he is less than enthused about the politics and procedures in the Army.
The closest to the truth about the tragedy of Pat Tillman is found in this book. The government had lied over and over again about the events that transpired that led to Pat’s untimely death. In this book, Krakauer does excellent research to get accounts of the people who were there, reports as to what really happened, and lays out all the miscommunications and bad decisions that led to that fateful day.
Although this book is titled ‘Where Men Win Glory-the Odyssey of Pat Tillman’, it is so much more than that; readers are given a thorough history of the conflict in the Middle East. At times I felt bogged and overwhelmed in minute detail. The war in Afghanistan is long and complex, and the author spends a significant part of the book describing events and ideology. Krakauer makes no attempt to hide his distaste and lack of respect for the Bush administration, and while it is easy to understand his point of view, I think he came on a little too thick, and it ended up more along the lines of angry tirades rather than thoughtful criticism.
Ultimately, though, the disservice that the US government bestowed upon Pat Tillman and his family, and the lessons that can be learned from this tragedy make this book worth reading. One man trying to do what he thought was right ended up being war propaganda, and the circumstances of his death led to a vast cover-up. Krakauer does a thorough job not only describing the events, but the man who was in the center of it all.



